By Sean Coughlan
©2005 BBC News
July 26, 2005
It's a crowded train in central London, and I'm sitting opposite an Asian
man carrying what looks like a large laptop bag.
Is it a coincidence that no one else is sitting near us? Is it an accident
that he's pushed out his corporate ID card so that it's clearly visible over
his jacket, hanging like the open page of a passport?
Public transport can be a world of unspoken signals and gestures - but am I
right in thinking that he looks self-conscious, sometimes burying his face in
his arms as though asleep?
When that woman getting into the carriage half-turned towards us and then
moved away, was that a deliberate decision, or was it a random commuter
choice? How would it feel to have someone literally turning their back on you?
Mind-games
I change Tube lines and in the next train I'm sitting close to a woman
wearing Islamic dress. But this time, all the seats are filled around her, and
the atmosphere feels relaxed.
What's going on in the thoughts of passengers? What judgements are they
making?
It's a mind-game being played out all over the Tube network, and indeed on
many trains and buses throughout the country. It's performed in silence, with
people unsure of their neighbours' motives and guilty about their own feelings
of suspicion.
Following the London bomb attacks, there have been stories swapped all over
the capital of people switching seats because of "suspicious"
passengers.
And targets of that suspicion have talked about their sense of frustration
at the unsubtle attention of other travellers.
Even though people say little when they're travelling, there's plenty going
on inside - fears of danger, changed routes, calculations to avoid risks,
guilt at making stereotypical assumptions, anger at being unfairly distrusted.
Stopped carrying rucksacks
In the rather unreal atmosphere of familiar places facing unfamiliar
threats, people are taking note of actions and appearances they wouldn't
usually see.
Hundreds of e-mails sent in to the BBC News website show how, in the uneasy
mood on public transport, we're thinking all kinds of unspoken thoughts.
There are flickers of bigotry and thinly-disguised racism, but there are
also convincingly understated descriptions of people's edginess - and examples
of how it is changing people's behaviour, including a number who say they have
stopped taking Tube trains.
Marcus, who says his family are Greek-Cypriot, has devised a strategy to
avoid "odd looks" on the Tube (which he attributes to his
Mediterranean appearance).
To make himself seem non-threatening, he now wears a Make Poverty History
wristband and makes a point of reading the Economist.
"Whilst this sounds ridiculous it does reassure people around me. Of
course, the whole thing is ridiculous but these are ridiculous times we are
living in," he writes.
An Asian reader says fears about what people are thinking have stopped him
carrying a rucksack.
"I do not take my rucksack to work anymore, which had my lunch and
work shirt. I would rather wear a dirty shirt left at work than be looked at
suspiciously. I also wear a T-shirt to work now, as I am afraid to wear too
much, after the shooting," he writes.
There are also people who have stopped wearing their MP3 players or iPods
because of worries about trailing wires or not hearing orders from the police.
Empty seat
Being on the receiving end of such a hostile atmosphere has persuaded
Leila, a white convert to Islam, to stop travelling by Tube altogether.
"I sensed people's fear of me because of my Muslim dress. Sometimes
people even preferred to stand rather than sit by me, leaving an empty seat
next to me."
Hindu and Sikh readers have also written to say they have experienced the
same sense of rejection.
"As I got on the tube with my rucksack, a fellow passenger saw me,
waited a second then got up, to wait on the platform for the next train,"
writes Dev.
Violence
This distrust between travellers is a phenomenon that feeds on itself, says
psychologist Gary Fitzgibbon, from the north London-based consultancy,
Fitzgibbon Associates.
"You've got a strange effect here. Everybody's awareness of a threat is
raised - and everyone is looking round suspiciously. So they're looking at
each other - and what they observe is people looking at them suspiciously,
which immediately raises their awareness that this person might be a threat.
"You can get very anxious situations arising - and in the extreme it
could lead to violence."
Mr Fitzgibbon says fear is a natural response to a threat - but the
prolonged media coverage, and the way that people continue to talk about the
bombings, can generate a response that is greater than the actual threat that
exists.
And amid such fears, he says that people can tend to seek people more like
themselves and to avoid those who are different.
Such a reaction, already witnessed by people sending in e-mails, would
threaten what a worried reader described as the capital's "multi-cultural
mini-world".
Readers' Comments
I can't avoid carrying a big rucksack with my mobile office in when I
travel. As I'm an Asian male that's been getting suspicious looks, I've taken
to carrying a bottle of wine as if I'm taking it home for dinner. It's ironic,
I don't even like wine, but it's a clear visual symbol that says I'm not a
fanatic Islamic bomber.
Elton Ali, Bermondsey, London
Before the start of July, as long as I can remember, there have been
warnings every few minutes in stations to watch out for unattended luggage.
There are signs on trains saying the same. The fact that each day now there
are so many calls to the police about such abandonded items speaks volumes for
how many unattended items people ignored before the first week in July.
Nick, Stirling, Scotland
Its often a tense atmosphere using public transport and I certainly am
thinking all the time about the people around me, judging, weighing them up in
my mind as a potential threat! i certainly dont fit any particular stereotype
of a would be suicide bomber but have still noticed peoples eyes on my back
pack. I want to say to everyone who is asian or looks to be a posible threat
that you should look around you and be aware that you are not the only ones
who are under suspicion. I am very wary of all sorts of people now and make no
appologies for it!!
Paul, London
I am British Asian. I was born here in London and I love the place. I have
been travelling on the Northern Line to work every morning for the past 8
years without incident. After the recent bombings, I've noticed that I've been
getting persistent looks and sneers on the underground. I also get the bus in
the evenings to London Bridge and usually sit upstairs. There have been times
when no one has sat next to me on a crowded bus. I don't look threatening in
the slightest. I do have a beard although I'm not Muslim. Peoples reactions
are understandable but they need to understand that I'm as terrified of being
bombed as they are. I have a blog at www.bozoduck.blogspot.com
Bijal Shah, London, UK
I think the author here has described the current situation perfectly. It
is almost impossible not to look around you as get onto a train these days. I
know I have done it and sat there worried. The only worry you have is what
you'd do if you think someone does look suspicious. You won't want to
challenge them but you won't want to move away for fear of inciting panic and
insulting to the person who will almost certainly turn out to be innocent of
nothing more than going to work with their gym kit.
Mat Fletcher, Stevenage
This all does seem incredibly surreal however it's not really surprising.
People I talk to are saying they feel we are in a 'war zone' and personal
safety is compromised. I would hope it is common sense to take actions not to
look suspicious. I do not carry a rucksack in London now, I use a sports bag
which, though inconvenient is less threatening. I am a white Englishman
(though can look mediterranean with some suntan) but I accept things must be
different now. Yes, I am worried, though I won't give in to my fears and will
continue to travel as before.
David Hill, High Wycombe & London, UK
You'll have to excuse me for being wary of my fellow passangers especially
young muslim males carrying backpacks. Next you'll be telling me I'm
infringing their human rights. I have a basic human right to travel to work
without a young muslim male carrying a backpack blowing the train up. Four
have done it already. At least four more tried unsuccessfully. Do I feel
guilty about offending someone? Not in the slightest.
James, London
I love living in London and one of the things I enjoy the most is the ¿International
City¿ aspect. I travel on the Northern Line to work everyday and the mood has
changed for the worse. I really feel sorry for my fellow commuters that people
would regard as of ¿Muslim appearance¿. But I think considering the loss of
life so far it is totally understandable the people are a lot more aware of
the people around them.
craig, London, ex-New Zealand
Sean Coughlin has summarised my feelings entirely. I travel overground into
London daily and then only travel four stops on the tube. I resolved on Sunday
to walk these instead. However it was raining on Monday so I took the easy, or
more accurately lazy option and took the Underground. I have travelled on the
tube for twenty years and in all that time have NEVER experienced the fear and
mistrust I did on Monday. I found myself reading the same sentence of my book
throughout the journey, looking up to give furtive glances to my fellow
passengers. They were doing the same themselves. I focussed on a chap who was
wearing a padded jacket and putting his hand into his inside pocket. Honestly,
I was absolutely fixated. The poor man was only fiddling with his ipod. The
guilt I felt about judging someone so quickly - and let's be frank - on the
grounds of their ethnic group made me feel quite ashamed. After all, the
suicide bombers, including the ones who got away, looked like ordinary young
men - even down to the New York embossed hooded top one of them was wearing.
Paranoia as opposed to well balanced vigilance is a terrorist's key weapon.
I've decided that if I can't travel the tube without looking at my fellow
passengers in fear then I shouldn't, quite frankly, be travelling at all.
Rosemary, Southend on Sea
Thanks to the author for bringing up the subject. However, in my opinion
many people are trying to justify this kind of behaviour by 'reasonable fear'.
Reasonable as it might be, it is no reason for racism. Not sitting next to
someone on the train is nothing but racism. It is not new, I think. People who
know what Asian culture is, what Islam is, the difference between Islam and
Hinduism, who have Asian friends, who truly have never been racist will not
behave like that. Those who will not seat next to Asains these days have
always been racist and only need a 'justifiable' reason to show it. Shame on
them. Fear is no good reason to make London tube a racially segregated form of
transport!
Natasha, Birmingham. UK
The way London commuters now feel is to be expected, but this is just the
start of what¿s to come. These London bombs will be a part of history that
will stand out as the date when a race split across Europe began. It¿s a
horrible world we are standing on the edge of.
Mark, Nottingham
That is why it is called terrorism the threat or use of violence, often
against the civilian population, to achieve political or social ends with the
aim of sowing fear and confusion.
Peter, Edinburgh, Scotland
I live in Bristol but use the tubes when I go to London for meetings. Last
wednesday I noticed a very odd atmosphere, tense with everyone looking around
at everyone else, especially each others bags. Paradoxically people were a lot
more polite than normal, with strangers actually talking to each other,
something I've never experienced in London before.
Matt Munro, Bristol, UK
I've read with interest the comments refered to in Coughlan's piece. As an
Asian man who has lived in London for the last eight years it seems absurd
that these terror attacks have awoken Asian people as to how theyre perceived
by other Londoners. My regulary bus journey into central London start with two
empty decks, as the journey continues the seats around me quickly fill up with
two people squeezed in per bench. Quite often I have a spare seat next to me,
unless there is almost no room elsewhere for passengers to sit. Now, why is
this? ...as a white comuter you should ask yourself do you always opt to sit
next to another white person - chances are, you've not changed your behaviour
after the bombing because you always did sit next to another white person
anyway.
jason, london
We have to face up to the fact that religions are just behavioural systems;
no different from cults, they exist only because of their perpetuation
mechanisms. Sadly, contempt and stigma seem to be as effective as anything -
whatever the results for life in the UK.
steve, london
It's natural people are going to be suspicous, nervous, anxious and aware
on the tubes. The Police are asking people to be extra vigliant. It saddens me
to hear that innocent, decent muslims and people of a different colour are
having to leave their bags at home, show their ID badge or read the Economist
BUT there are people out there wanting to kill us. This is an extreme
situation. Until this moves away, as I am hoping beyond hope that it does, I
think patience and understanding is necessary from all people in the capital.
Helen, Manchester
Now the general public has been introduced to the plight of the black man.
I am a chemistry PhD student, a research and teaching assistant but that does
not seem to be enough to make others feel comfortable. I too make my own
declarations: doing work on my computer, grading papers or reading some
chemical journal with a molecule in full view, but I still see some women
clutch their purses a little more tightly or some men making sure their
wallets are still there as I pass. To survive, you have to train yourself to
just let it go. Perhaps when the fear subsides and the london public returns
to a fair sense of normalcy, we will learn the more appropriate of the two
lesson here: Dont judge.
Noel, United States
I too am responding in a somewhat irrational way to the threat of bombings.
Just the other day I was at Camberwell Green, waiting for a bus, and I had all
sorts of disturbing thoughts running through my head. Instead of getting on
any one of 3 buses, I decided to wait for a bus which starts its route at
Camberwell Green, as it would be empty, and the driver would have just done
his security check. Then as I was about to get on an asian man carrying a
large holdall boarded the bus. I was terrified, there were lots of passengers,
and that in itself had unnerved me. I got on and stayed as far from the man as
I could, and kept stealing glances at him. All the while my mind was working
overtime as I tried to assure myself of my safety. Luckily my journey was a
short one, and as I disembarked, I half expected to see the bus explode as I
walked away, or to hear about it later that evening on the news - when I heard
nothing I felt incredibly guilty that I had naturally assumed that the
"innocent" asian man was a terrorist. We all need to be extrememly
careful of how we regard others in light of these terrible events, or our
multicultural society (which we should be proud of)will turn into a society
blighted by racist crimes/divisions.
Anon, London
I got onto the busy carriage of a train on Saturday. There was an empty
seat which everyone getting onto the carriage walked past. The seat to the
left of the empty one was taken up by a man of African origin and he had a
large holdall by his feet. I need say no more. So, I deliberately asked in a
clear voice if the seat was taken (as if I needed to ask!) he smiled said help
yourself and so I sat down. I understand that people are on edge but let's not
allow the terrorists to drive a wedge between the different races and cultures
that make up a country and home which everyone should be proud of. Whether
you're black, brown, yellow, white or green, with a rucksack or a bunch of
flowers, I'll sit next to you!
Sarah, Berkshire
The events have indeed affected us. Today I saw an Asian man running away
from a bus: everyone tuned and stared at him until he turned a corner... to
catch another bus. I think we were not vigilant enough before. We should just
find the right balance between paranoia and indifference.
Maria, London
When they look at me what do they see? A suspect terrorist? It's amazing
that by just wearing a cloth on my head it can change a simple mans view of
myself. I do not blame him. I feel for him as he thinks twice about getting on
the same carriage as me. I feel for the woman over there who is watching my
every move - from increasing the volume on my ipod to scratching my arm. I
feel for those passengers who are so scared by me reaching into my handbag
searching for my little blue extras (chewing gum).... I feel for them all. I
won't change, I won't be accepted. Apologies.
Sama Afroz Khan, London
I was on a bus in Scotland this weekend with a gaggle of Spanish teenagers.
An elderly sikh man with a long beard and turban got on the bus and they all
stared at him. They were speaking in Spanish, but they muttered "Osama
Bin Laden", at which point everyone turned to stare at this poor man who
was just (trying to) mind his own business. I was shocked that these teenagers
felt that this was an acceptable way to behave. Let us be more aware of this
ignorant behaviour, and if we see it happening we should all speak up to
defend the innocent.
F M Watt, Edinburgh
I saw another new and interesting development which may well be useful to
others - a man of middle eastern origin carrying his luggage in a transparent
polythene bag thus avoiding further supicious looks
gill sheldrake, andover
I have just read the article on the discomfort of strangers, and felt I had
to leave a message to express my sorrow that people are being avoided on
public transport, sorely because they are Asian or of Mediterranean
appearance. Surely we cannot do this to people just because they are of the
same race/religion to the bombers, it has got to stop. I'm sure they are
feeling uneasy already, we should be standing with them and not avoiding them.
I thought that we had moved on from the racisim in the 60's, it sounds a very
similar story to me...
Hannah, Essex
Being an Asian, I have noticed many people looking at me
curiously/suspiciously while on trains and buses. I try to ignore those
staring by solving SuDoKu puzzles but does not always help. Also, I have
swapped my slightly bigger bag for a softer smaller one because of the
'rucksack phenomenon'. Hopefully time will make things get back to normal.
AK Khatri, London Uk
I have travelled on the underground a couple of times since the bombings,
and have experienced my fellow citizens react in a variety of ways. Most
people have been subtle, some are rude, however, people have also moved closer
towards me to show that thet too 'are not afraid'. All this is understandable,
the last two weeks have been stressful for commuters. The question I am asking
is how long will this last? The treat is large at the moment because the
bombers are still on the run. But what will reactions be this time next year?
My hope is that we will behave in a proportional manner. We must always
remeber that the bombers main aim is to divide, they will have done a good job
if we become forever suspicious of each other.
Mace, Leeds
As an avid people-watcher I've witnessed train commuters' personas change
over the past couple of weeks. Even here on the train into Newcastle many
miles from recent events in London. Instead of the usual drab and emotionless
exteriors of people on the way to the daily grind, commuters seem wide-eyed
and wary. Not outwardly so, but just veiled glances and suspicious thoughts.
The impact of terrorism is far and wide.
, Newcastle
The traditionally safe notion of not talking to strangers, and the
Londoners¿ habit of remaining silent and avoiding eye contact on the tube (to
avoid provocation among other reasons) now play against us. It is now an
unhappy truism that anyone darker than the average Celt is likely to be viewed
with a degree of suspicion, especially if wearing a rucksack or heavy
clothing. I suggest we start saying good morning to each other; comment on the
weather. An impending suicide bomber would be edgy and nervous, and not in the
least bit talkative. Then¿s the time to get suspicious.
Ed, London, UK
There is definitely an increase in tension and suspicion amongst users of
public transport since the bombings. I carry a small back-pack with my gym kit
each morning and, despite being Scottish and distinctly fair in complexion, I
have attracted suspicious glances from fellow passengers. If I am being viewed
with suspicion, goodness knows what it must be like for people of
middle-eastern or asian appearance - a whole lot worse, I imagine. I'm ashamed
to admit that, despite myself, I have found myself checking out fellow
passengers, particularly those of asian appearance, if they are carrying
rucksacks. However, I have now realised that to do this allows the terrorists
to win - they want to create fear, suspicion and ethnic hatred. We cannot
allow them to do this. Do not view every backpacked passenger as a potential
terrorist and refuse to sit near them. You've got a far greater chance of
being killed by a passing car - does this mean you are going to stop crossing
the street?
Brian, Edinburgh
See also: I'm Brown, On the Metro, and Messing With Your Head