By Judy Tseng
Special to ModelMinority.com
July 4, 2007
It has become required viewing in Asian American
Studies and Ethnic Studies classes nationwide: “Who
Killed Vincent Chin,” a documentary produced by Renee
Tajima and Christine Choi, chronicles the June 19,
1982 Detroit hate crime that took the life of a young
man a day before his wedding and left a community
reeling from the leniency afforded to the murderers.
For those who have not seen this film yet, a very
brief synopsis of this chapter in Asian American
history follows:
On June 19, 1982, Vincent Chin and his friends were at
his bachelor party in Detroit, when they got into an
argument with two white autoworkers,
Ronald Ebens and Michael Nitz. The two stated, “It’s
because of you little motherfuckers that we’re out of
work!” Ebens and Nitz later followed Chin to a
McDonald's parking lot. They beat Chin with a baseball
bat, cracking his skull. Chin died a few days later,
the day before his wedding. Ebens and Nitz did not
even spend a night in jail, instead getting three
years of probation and a $3000.00 fine, because Judge
Charles Kaufman thought they were otherwise upstanding
citizens. Interestingly enough, Judge Kaufman, who
died in 2004, had been a navigator for the Army Air
Force in World War II; after 27 missions, his plane
was shot down and he was held by the Japanese as a
prisoner of war. Perhaps his experience in Japan led
him to view Asians, as well as Asian Americans, as the
enemy.
Later federal civil-rights cases brought against the
two defendants were appealed, and the juries acquitted
each of them. A civil lawsuit was filed against
Ronald Ebens and resulted in a $1.5 million judgment
for Chin’s estate, but Ebens disposed of his assets
and went into hiding. The astounding blows dealt by
the legal system galvanized community organizing and
political action among Asian Americans back in the
days when there were few Asian American organizations,
no internet portals such as ModelMinority.com, and few
Asian Americans in public offices, much less the
judiciary. Lily Chin, Vincent’s grief-stricken
mother, moved back to China, returning only in 2001
shortly before her death.
Twenty five years after Vincent Chin’s murder, this
June and July, Asian Americans across the United
States have taken part in remembering the murder of
Vincent Chin and the lessons learned. Curtis Chin of
Asian Americans for Progress spearheaded the effort to
organize nationwide town halls to show the documentary
“Who Killed Vincent Chin?” and discuss the issue of
hate crimes. Though he is not related to Vincent
Chin, Curtis Chin and his family also lived in Detroit
in the early eighties and knew Vincent Chin’s family.
“It was a very small Chinese community in Detroit.
Our family had one of the oldest restaurants that was
literally at the center of Chinatown,” recalls Chin,
who now lives in the Los Angeles area.
Though he does not personally have memories of Vincent
Chin because he was much younger than Vincent, Curtis
Chin says, “But I do remember hearing that he had been
beaten up and that he was in the hospital. I also
specifically remember seeing the wedding invitation on
our kitchen counter and thinking, I guess we can throw
this away. In the background, you'll see my dad in
‘Who Killed Vincent Chin.’”
On June 19, 2007, community members in Detroit
organized a five-hour-long session covering hate crime
legislative updates, discussion about the Vincent Chin
case trials, and coalition building. In attendance
were Khin Aung from the Asian American Legal Defense
and Education Fund (based in New York), Michael Lin of
the Organization of Chinese Americans, and Vincent Eng
of the Asian American Justice Center in Washington,
D.C.
After the discussion, there was a memorial service at
Vincent Chin’s grave at Forest Lawn cemetery.
Reverend Daniel Shen of the Chinese Alliance Church
presided. Amy Lee, Vincent Chin's aunt and the
younger sister of Lily Chin, was also present for the
eulogies and poetry readings.
Frank Wu, Dean of Wayne State University law school,
gave a dynamic speech extemporaneously. Remarking on
the Vincent Chin case, he stated, "It brought together
Asian Americans as Asian Americans and forged a
movement. It made this group of people who had very
little in common realize that even if their ancestors
hated each other, they had a common cause in America.
That's why this case still matters."
Professor Teresa Mah of the University of Chicago,
said she “thought the Detroit event was well worth
driving from Chicago to attend. The service at the
cemetery was especially moving.... Frank Wu was
terrific, and it was great to see such a broad array
of people in the audience.”
Prof. Mah was also an organizer of a similar event in
Chicago. Panelists at the Chicago event were Diana
Lin and Myron Quon from the Asian American Institute,
Bill Yoshino from the Japanese American Citizens
League, and Rima Kapitan from the Council on
American-Islamic Relations. Of that event, she was
“very happy with the turnout, the quality of the
panel, and the engagement by the audience. There were
quite a few young people in the audience, which was
great, and it was a valuable opportunity to build
partnering relationships with our cosponsors.”
The commemorative event organized in Los Angeles on
June 24, 2007 drew about 100 people. Opening remarks
were given by Assemblyman Mike Eng, State Board of
Equalization Vice Chair Judy Chu, and Lilian Ileto,
the mother of Joseph Ileto, a Filipino American postal
worker gunned down in 1999 by a white supremacist on a
shooting rampage.
Panelists included: Vivien Hao of Asian Pacific
Americans for Progress, Shazia Kamal of the Muslim
Public Affairs Council, Hamid Khan of South Asian
Network, Stewart Kwoh of APA Legal Center, Renee
Tajima-Pena, filmmaker, professor, and co-director of
“Who Killed Vincent Chin?”, and Robin Toma of the LA
County Human Relations Commission.
Washington, D.C. activists held their event on
Saturday, June 23rd 2007 at the Martin Luther King Jr.
Memorial Library in Chinatown. First, the audience
viewed “Who Killed Vincent Chin” and had a
facilitated discussion about how the Vincent Chin
tragedy, despite how far we have come in the civil
rights movement, is still salient in the APA community
today in light of 9/11 and the Virginia Tech shooting
tragedy. Professor Larry Shinagawa of the University
of Maryland Asian American Studies Program was the
featured speaker.
That same day, Boston also held its commemorative
event and town hall at the New Star Community Art
School. One prominent guest speaker was Grace Lee, a
co-founder of Massachusett’s Asian American Commission
and former Chief of Civil Rights in the Norfolk County
District Attorney’s Office. Leveret Wing, the new
Executive Director of the Asian American Commission,
also spoke at the event. Organizers also gave a
report on the “Quincy Four” case, where four Asian
Americans– Chinese Progressive Association organizer
Karen Chen, Quon Mah Thin, Tat M. Yuen, and Howard Ng
– were assaulted and pepper sprayed by the Quincy
police after they left an engagement party on April
30, 2006. The event was sponsored by the Asian
American Resource Workshop, Chinatown Resident
Association, and Chinese Progressive Association.
Portland, Oregon will hold its town hall event on
Saturday, July 7th from 3:00 pm - 6:00 pm at the OHS
Doernbecher Children’s Hospital, 11th Floor
Auditorium. Organized by Byron Wong, the session will
have as panelists Ms. Tracey Lam (Producer, KATU
News), Mr. John Kodachi, JD (Lawyer; President of
Japanese American Citizens League), Dr. Patti Sakurai,
PhD (Professor of Ethnic Studies, Oregon State
University ), and Mr. William Chin, J.D., M.S.
(Professor of Legal Analysis and Writing, Lewis and
Clark Law School). Sponsors of the Portland event are
the Korean American Citizens League, Japanese American
Citizens League, KBOO Radio, APA Compass, and the
Oregon Minority Lawyers Association.
Last, but not least, on July 14, 2007, Durham, North
Carolina will be the site of the final event this year
commemorating the death of Vincent Chin. North
Carolina unfortunately has also been the site of some
hate crimes against Asian Americans: in 1989, Jim
Ming-hai Loo was murdered at a Raleigh bar by Lloyd
and Robert Piche, and in 2002, Lily Wang was shot and
killed by a fellow N.C. State graduate student, a
white male Asiaphile who thereafter committed suicide.
The event, co-sponsored by the National Association
of Asian American Professionals-North Carolina and the
North Carolina Asian Pacific American Bar Association,
will feature a showing of the Vincent Chin
documentary, followed by a discussion on hate crimes
and a trek to a sushi restaurant nearby.
When Curtis Chin is asked what motivated him to
initiate this nationwide commemoration of the Vincent
Chin hate crime, he replies, “Well, it was a personal
issue with me, but I also felt that APA community has
very few figures like Vincent and we need to remember
him the same way that the gay and lesbian community
remembers Matthew Shepard or the African American
community remembers the four little girls in Selma,
Alabama.”